"He only is my rock and my salvation, my fortress; I shall not be greatly shaken. Ps62:2

Thursday, February 21, 2008

True Frugality

I'm really confused by what a lot of people are calling frugal living. I'm always reading about moms who cut coupons in the name of frugality. They not only cut coupons, they collect individual store coupons and post about their conquests trekking from one store to another garnering deals on shaving cream and hair color. They claim victory upon victory in the purchase of numerous items for nearly nothing. They often gloat and brandish their coupon madness for all to see. Ninety-nine cent packages of hot-dogs are "the bomb!"

This way of thinking is so strange to me. To me all that is absolute slavery.

First off, "them that do" are slaves to the "bargain". They have to have "it" if "it's" a "deal". If they have a coupon, or there's a sale, they have to GO. Worse than all that, they go from store, to store, to store, to store to get "it". They spend hours cutting, organizing and pondering sales flyers. They plan their weeks around sales. They are made happy by saving "something" and are giddy at the thought of the next "savings". They drive and drive endlessly to get it. Where do they come by all that time?! It baffles me. How is that frugal living?

I'm all for saving, but what do these folks really get out of it? To me slavery is when you "have" to do something "because...". You have to go to CVS because you can get 5 of these with 2 coupons and the sale and the rebate for 4.5 cents! You HAVE to get your dry goods HERE because they are 25 cents cheaper.

I have a cousin like this. She can not shop at one grocery. She has to hit them all. She spends hours with her Sunday paper memorizing, cutting and planning her purchases. Why not just go when you need to! Why not buy just what you need? If you are using coupons, most likely you are acting on the dictates of the manufacturer. Is it really something you need? If it is, great! But how often is it...really? Is it really frugal living to "live" for the next "deal"?


What about true frugality? True frugality, to me, is using a bit less. It's finding ways to change your lifestyle for "less". It's sometimes about spending MORE so you can LIVE. You can't LIVE on Ding Dongs no matter how cheap you get them. I see more coupons for "Ding-Dongs" than I do for milk. Won't you be better nourished buying quality all-natural meat than hot-dogs?

True frugality for me is buying toilet paper at Kroger instead of Target because if I have to go to Target it takes an entire afternoon, 2 whiny kids who hate being there, a MINimum of $200 a trip, which always includes something I didn't plan to buy (because that's really what Target is for!), 8 miles more gas than the grocery store, eating fast food (yuck!) and complete and utter exhaustion. Not to mention all the other things I couldn't do because I HAD to go there...,

I didn't get to bake my bread, read that history book to son, practice ballet with daughter, rest! I didn't get to look out my window at the snow falling or put pictures in my scrapbook. I didn't get to sit by the fire and drink a cup of tea while visiting with a friend, I didn't get to call my dad.

Don't get me wrong...I love Target. The point is, sometimes I choose to spend more and buy a few things at Kroger because I'm there and I want TO GO HOME AND STAY HOME! It's so worth my time (financially and otherwise) to make that choice. That is true frugality to me. Staying home more. Not putting wear and tear on your self, your family, your car, your self, to shop, shop, shop.. wearing your self out!!

True frugality is spending money to learn to plant a garden to sustain your family rather than spend the time cutting coupons. True frugality is about priorities. True frugality is about consumption and choices. It's about saving the cable bill so you can buy games to play with your kids. It's about saving the cost of a Wii so that your children will have time to read the best books ever written!

As you can imagine, I could go on and on. I know that there is something appealing to every mom in "saving" and finding bargains. We're drawn to info about it like moths to flames. But do we remember that the gate is wide that leads to destruction. When we run, the race of endurance we better be running the right race. Idolatry comes in all shapes and sizes, even coupon shapes and sizes.

My prayer for myself is that my frugality will come in the wisdom to make good choices and pass that wisdom on to my children.
We don't have an abundance to spend. We still have debt we're working our way out of, but that has more to do with God and his provision and lessons for us, as anything.

I write all this not to judge anyone who loves to cut those coupons, but just as a reminder to myself that it's okay for me to buy wooden spoons at Kroger instead of the dollar store. After all, I'm cooking healthy meals for my family using them...instead of going to Taco Bell.

8 comments:

EEEEMommy said...

I completely agree that TIME is MONEY! My time is so much more valuable.
I do think that there are people who really consider shopping for bargains a hobby. And there are people who DON'T consider shopping and going from store to store comparing prices to be at all stressful. I do. But sometimes I feel guilty because I'm not like them. If I ever feel that way again, I'm coming back to read this post! :)

Dana said...

I don't go from store to store, but I do have the CVS thing figured out. It isn't stressful and I don't feel like I HAVE to get all my dry goods in one place, for whatever reason.

You are lucky in that you have several choices for shopping where you live. I don't have that luxury. I go get groceries once a month. We usually have to fill in with things a few things later on. When I do my shopping, I do go to several stores, but they're within 1/4 mile of each other. I do spend some time planning my trip, but it's not all about coupons. It's about where I can get what we need, for the best price, and with the smallest effort.

With the price of gas, it doesn't make much sense to drive all over town to save $1. BUT if you can save several dollars by driving 1/2 mile, I'm all for it. Like I said, I usually do this just once each month.

Part of our frugality (and, yes, I consider myself to be very frugal) is stocking up when I find a good price so that it will last us until we get the same good price again. (These things run in cycles, you know.)

Sometimes for us, frugality is being able to spend less so we can live more, not the other way around. Our finances are very limited, and if I didn't try to stretch our budget, we wouldn't have extra for any extra that most people count as "living". An example would be our internet connection. I have to make it pay for itself, or we can't afford it. If I can't save enough from our regular budget to pay the bill, our internet connection will have to be one of the first things to go.

Same goes for things like trips to Wonderlab, a bigger city library, the zoo, etc. We don't have money in the budget for those types of things. But, if I can save x$ somewhere by using coupons, rebates, etc., we'll get to do some of those things. If I decided to buy everything at Kroger, we'd not have extra money to do anything.

I don't want this to sound like a pitty party. I'm happy to be able to clip coupons and figure out the deals. Maybe it's a gift. LOL

By the way, if a trip to Target that was in, or near, my hometown took all afternoon and I spent a minimum of $200, I wouldn't go there either.

I also thing I'm teaching the girls how to be frugal and not take money for granted. Before we go into a store, we always pray to use our money wisely and for God to help us spend His money in a way that will be honoring to Him.

Also, we always, always, ALWAYS shop with a list so we don't end up buying those things we didn't plan to buy. Impulse buying can wreck a budget.

And, we never buy Ding-Dongs--coupon or no. :-) However, a package of the powdered sugared donuts always follow us home. It's a treat for the girls that comes once a month. They look forward to it and it' become a tradition of sorts.

I've written a novel.

In summation...uhem....your way works because of where you live. It won't necessarily work for someone who lives in a rural community who is on a strict budget.

If I bought my spoons at Kroger (which I might do sometime), I'd cook healthy meals using them. But if I didn't buy the spoons, I'd still cook a healthy meal for them. The closest Taco Bell is almost 20 miles away.

Sometimes frugality is buying what you have to have to get by, not buying what you think you have to have to get by. If I have plastic or metal spoons that will work just fine, the frugal answer for me it to not buy spoons. Did that make any sense?

I've written a novel. I apologize.

Blessings--
Dana

Netherfieldmom said...

Tag, you're it! Check out my blog to find the rules...

Anonymous said...

That was a great post!
Susan

Joni said...

Yes! Yes! Yes! I used to spend time running to Sam's Club, Aldi's and Kroger for the groceries, etc. And then one day I woke up and realized, "I hate this!" and with three young children, I would rather pay a little bit more at Kroger and get it all there. What wise words, Melissa. I feel just like you on this one.

Netherfieldmom said...

I agree with you on this, but it sounds like this kind of "shopping" is not about shopping. It's a form of a hobby for people who don't really cultivate hobbies anymore. We have grown up in an era of shopping as an activity, consumerism for its own ends. Weird, in my book. I have posted about senior citizens in my life who have hobbies compared with those who don't. Quite a shocking comparison. I agree with all your points--except the Wii--which i don't own, but got to use over the holiday. It is the first video game I was ever interested in, ever, because I saw my 78 yr. old MIL playing with my 67 yr. old dad and 14 yr. old daughter and 21 yr. old cousin, everyone laughing and off the couch.

Coupons, schmoupons, I want to be home making tacos with my kids. :)

Stacey said...

Thanks for putting into words what I've always felt but never took the time to "process"! No more guilty non-coupon-using trips to the store! :)

Nicki said...

Hmmm...I agree with some of what you are saying. Although, I think that some of the comments about couponing and shopping at various stores, are painted with a rather wide brush. I do shop at various stores, however, I do so in a way that stopping at each of these stores is integrated into our weekly schedule. If we are going to the library we can take the route that takes us past this store, so that I can grab some sale items.

I use coupons but I don't buy junk food. :)

I go to CVS and pile up on their deals. I currently have enough toiletries to last my family for the next 3-4 months...and I paid pennies for these things. That has helped cut my grocery budget which has allowed us to put more money towards things like sponsoring a Compassion child. In the last week, I have used some of my stockpile to give to the family down the street who is going through a job loss. I also give some of the things that I get for free, or close to free, to my church's pantry. And all I had to do was clip some coupons, look through an ad, and stop at the store on my way to the library, or on the way home from church on Sunday night. This does not take away from time with my children. It shows them how a little extra effort on my part can be a blessing to so many others. (a Compassion child, the neighbors struggling down the street, someone who comes to the church in need.)

I'm not saying that this is the way everyone should do it. But, I'm also not saying that those who do not practice frugality the way I do, or share my same thoughts, are not practicing "true frugality". I think that true frugality is relative to the one being frugal.

It's hard to understand the tone of comment when it is made in the written word. Please, know that I'm writing this in a non-confrontational tone. Let's just imagine that we're sipping tea together and having a laid back conversation about our lives as homemakers. That really is all I'm doing here and I apologize if I wasn't able to write in a way that conveys that. :)